1. Home
  2. Prepare Your Home
  3. Loss of Power
  4. Solar vs. Fuel Generators

Solar Vs. Fuel

When you’re planning for power outages, both solar generators and fuel generators can play important roles - but they shine in different situations. Instead of thinking "either/or," it helps to understand what each one does best and which one makes the most sense as your first purchase. This page is designed to help you quickly compare the two, understand what each one does best, and decide which is the better first step for your situation. You’ll also see why, over time, many households benefit from having both.

No Electricity
What Each Generator Does Best

Solar Generators

Harnesses energy from the sun:

  • Best for quiet, indoor-safe power for electronics, medical devices, fans, and small appliances.
  • Can recharge daily from the sun, especially helpful in long outages.
  • Very quiet, no fumes, and low maintenance.
  • Limited by battery capacity and panel size, and a higher upfront cost for whole-home use.

Fuel Generators

Uses gasoline, diesel, and propane:

  • Great for high power needs (fridges, freezers, well pumps, multiple circuits).
  • Run as long as you have fuel.
  • Must be used outdoors due to exhaust.
  • Noisy, needs regular maintenance (oil changes, testing, etc.).

Both can be incredibly useful. The question is: what problems are you trying to solve first?
Answer this question, and you’ll know which purchase to make first.

No Electricity
Which Generator Should You Buy First?

There isn’t a single "right" answer for everyone. The best place to start depends on what you’re most worried about when the lights go out.
Let’s look at both fuel and solar.

When a Fuel Generator Makes More Sense as Your First Purchase

A fuel generator often makes more sense as your "first line of defense" if you’re worried about losing the big, expensive things in your home.

You might want to start with a fuel generator if:

  • Protecting your fridge and freezer is your top priority - A properly sized fuel generator can run your fridge and freezer in timed blocks, so everything stays safely cold.
  • You rely on high-draw equipment - Fuel generators are better suited to power higher-demand equipment. High draw equipment includes well pumps, sump pumps, and larger space heaters.
  • Your outages are usually short but disruptive - If most of your power outages last from a few hours to a couple of days, a fuel generator shines. You can run it in intervals to power your needs, then shut it down to save fuel.
  • You’re able and willing to store fuel safely - This means committing to follow safe storage guidelines and rotation protocol.
  • Budget-wise, you need the most watts for the least money - Watt for watt, a fuel generator usually costs less up front than a comparable solar/battery system.

If your top priority is keeping food from spoiling and running a few big loads during relatively short outages, a fuel generator is often the most practical first purchase. Learn more about fuel generators for emergency power.

When a Solar Generator is the Better First Purchase

A solar generator can be a better starting point if you’re thinking more about quiet, everyday usability and long-term resilience than raw power.

You might want to start with a solar generator if:

  • Indoor safety and quiet matter most - You want backup power that can safely live inside your home. There are no fumes nor running back and forth to the backyard.
  • You worry about longer or repeated outages - If you’re in an area with regular rolling blackouts, wildfire shutoffs, ice storms, or hurricanes, the ability to recharge from the sun can stretch your preparedness beyond your stored fuel.
  • Fuel storage isn’t practical where you live - In condos, apartments, or tighter neighborhoods, storing gasoline or multiple propane tanks may not be realistic or allowed.
  • You prefer something very low-maintenance - Solar generators are generally lower maintenance, especially if you keep them charged and test them periodically. There are no carburetors, oil changes, or pull-starts.
  • You want to be a bit more discreet - A humming fuel generator can be heard and noticed, which matters in dense neighborhoods or situations where you don’t want to draw attention. A solar generator quietly humming away indoors is much less obvious.

Verdict: If your top priority is quiet, indoor-safe power for electronics and medical gear, and you like the idea of recharging from the sun during longer outages, a solar generator can be an excellent first step. Learn more about solar generators for emergency power.

No Electricity
Best Strategy: Using Both Together
    FUEL
  • Handle big loads: fridge, freezer, well pump, selected circuits.
  • Run for a few hours at a time to get the big jobs done quickly.
  • Top off your solar generator and battery banks when the sun isn’t cooperating.
    SOLAR
  • Power phones, radios, lights, fans, routers, and medical gear quietly through the night.
  • Cover overnight needs without the noise and fuel use of a fuel generator.
  • Reduce how often you need to run the fuel generator (saving fuel and reducing noise, and wear).

Getting the Best of Both Worlds

Over time, many families choose to add both a fuel generator and a solar generator. Instead of relying on one tool to do everything, this creates a layered power strategy where fuel does the heavy lifting and solar provides daily comfort.

Frequently Asked Questions

Quick answers to common questions about choosing between solar and fuel generators.

  • A solar generator can be a better fit for long or repeated outages because it can recharge from the sun each day, especially if you have a decent solar panel setup. A fuel generator can absolutely help in longer outages too, but it’s limited by how much fuel you can safely store and access. In many homes, the strongest setup is a combination: fuel for heavy loads, solar for quiet, everyday essentials.

  • Most portable solar generators are not designed to run an entire house the way a larger standby or whole-home fuel generator can. They are better suited for smaller loads like phones, laptops, medical devices, lights, fans, and sometimes a refrigerator for limited periods. Whole-home solar and battery systems do exist, but they require a larger investment and proper installation.

  • Yes. As long as your solar generator supports AC charging (plugging into a standard household outlet), you can run your fuel generator for a few hours to charge the solar generator’s battery. This lets you save fuel and then switch back to quiet, indoor power once the fuel generator is off.

  • A solar generator’s battery and inverter are designed for indoor use, as long as you follow the manufacturer’s guidelines and keep the unit ventilated. Solar panels themselves stay outside. Fuel generators must always stay outdoors because they produce carbon monoxide and other exhaust. They should never be run in a garage, basement, or enclosed space.

  • If your main worry is losing a freezer or fridge full of food, a fuel generator often gives you more watts for the money and may be the better first step. If your priority is quiet, indoor-safe power for phones, laptops, and medical equipment, and you don’t have a good way to store fuel, a smaller solar generator can be a better match. Over time, adding the other type gives you a stronger, layered backup plan.